Defense Base Act Compensation Blog

The Modern Day DBA Casualty

Remember Them, Too

Posted by defensebaseactcomp on May 25, 2009

Don’t Contractors Count When We Calculate the Costs of War?Contractor Casket

  An Arlington National Cemetery caisson carries the body of retired Air Force Col. Michael W. Butler, who was killed while working as a private contractor in Iraq. (2007 Photo By Charles Dharapak — Associated Press)

By Steven Schooner

Monday, May 25, 2009

Despite the light that Memorial Day will shine, briefly, on the U.S. death tolls in Iraq and Afghanistan, don’t expect an accurate accounting of the real human cost of our military actions abroad. The numbers you’ll see — mostly likely just under 5,000 fatalities — won’t tell the whole story.

As of June 2008 (the most recent reliable numbers available publicly), more than 1,350 civilian contractor personnel had died in Iraq and Afghanistan supporting our efforts. About 29,000 contractors had been injured, more than 8,300 seriously.

But don’t expect President Obama to remember or thank the contractor personnel who died supporting our troops or diplomatic missions. Instead, expect to see contractor personnel in Iraq and Afghanistan continue to be portrayed as expendable profiteers, adventure seekers or marginalized members of society who are not entitled to the same respect or value given to members of the military.

That portrayal, of course, is neither accurate nor fair. Most contractors perform tasks that a generation ago would have been done by uniformed service members. A significant number of these contractors are former members of the military who believe they’re answering the same call they would have answered had the crisis arisen while they were on active duty.

Many of the victims are Iraqis and other foreign nationals working under U.S. government contracts. But whether or not they are U.S. citizens, the central fact remains: If our military was less dependent on contractors, these fatalities probably would have been of uniformed service members

An honest, accurate tally is important because the public — and, for that matter, Congress — does not grasp the level of the military’s reliance on contractors in the battle area, nor the extent of these contractors’ sacrifices. Simply put, the contemporary, heavily outsourced U.S. military cannot effectively fight or sustain itself without a significant, if not unprecedented, presence of embedded contractors. In Iraq, our contractor-to-troop ratio has exceeded 1 to 1. The State Department admitted last summer that it could not remain in Iraq without heavy reliance on private security.

An accurate tally is critical to any discussion of the costs and benefits of our efforts in Iraq and Afghanistan. War proponents benefit from the massive contractor presence because it permits them to suggest that our military presence is smaller than what is actually required. And to the extent that the public cares about military fatalities, the human cost of our efforts in Iraq appears much smaller than it would if we didn’t rely so heavily on contractors.

In 2006 and 2007, the contractor death rate climbed dramatically. After much smaller numbers during the first three years of the Iraq war, at least 301 civilian contractors died in 2006. At least 353 civilian contractors died in Iraq in 2007, while 901 U.S. military personnel died there. In other words, in 2007, contractors accounted for more than one in four deaths associated with the U.S. occupation.

If anything, the number of contractor deaths is understated. Last year, for the first time, Congress began to require the Pentagon, the State Department and the Agency for International Development to keep track of how many contractors are working in Iraq and Afghanistan and how many have been killed and wounded. The Defense Department recently conceded that it is trying but is not yet up to the task.

The Labor Department generates but does not publish data quarterly on contractor deaths, but only because insurance claims are filed with its Division of Longshore and Harbor Workers Compensation. (American contractors are required to provide Defense Base Act insurance, which falls under that program.) If a contractor’s family or employer does not seek insurance compensation, that death isn’t counted. There’s no doubt that the allied death toll is significantly higher than reported and that contractors bear a far greater burden in this regard than the public appreciates.

In a representative democracy, public awareness of the human cost of our engagements abroad is critical. If we’re going to tally the human cost of our efforts, the public deserves a full accounting.

The writer, a retired Army Reserve judge advocate, is co-director of the Government Procurement Law program at George Washington University. He was a White House procurement policy official from 1996 to 1998. He published an academic article, “Why Contractor Fatalities Matter,” in the Autumn 2008 issue of the Army War College’s quarterly journal, Parameters.

Why Contractor Casualties Matter


6 Responses to “Remember Them, Too”

  1. Sheila said

    Contractors do matter. Their blood is just a red as the soldiers also dying for our country. Many of them are prior military and american police officers… I think the public has simply not been properly educated on their exact functions. Hopefully we can ban together and change that.

    Sheila Wetherbee
    Widow of KIA Darrell Wetherbee Iraq/2006

    • Di said

      Another thought about our brave contractor army is that we could not continue to carry on over most of the world as a police enforcing civil law without them. We have no draft and a great proportion of the fighting and training teams are made up of contractors….it’s the way our government chose to fight this conflict and secure our nation. We may have 130,000 troops over in the Afghanni area but we have more than 100,000 contractors there who by the way are paid a very pricey amount .

      • brit guy said

        It is a shame people do not know the facts. Whilst most western contractors are paid well I.e. Americans Australians Brits Kiwis. Most of the workers from the poorer nations I.e. Philippines Bangladeshi Indian where paid less than $20 a day. And they make up a bulk of the contractors working in these war zones.

        One point that rankles more than any is the constant reference to what contractors got paid. Yes we were paid well. Let me ask you question would you not expect to be paid well if in your daily life you faced insurgent attacks the possibility of being killed or maimed for life.

        This blog is for the injured and killed in the support of the war terror who have been abandoned by those who said they would take care of us and our loved ones should the worse happen.

        I hear very little about the cost or earnings of the attorneys paid to fight to deny us our entitlement. These people and I use that word lightly earn far more than the contractors working in war zones. Nor do I hear about the adjusters who earn bonuses based on what they save in denying our benefits.

  2. […] Remember Them Too […]

  3. Sheila Wetherbee said

    “…who by the way are paid a very pricey amount .”

    What is your point?

  4. Shirley said

    I find this to sad to comment about, because i feel the Iraq War didn’t have to be.
    I have read a lot of article about contracted Firms and contractors, i feel the Firms were at the advantage here.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: